Tuesday, April 30, 2013

Research Proposal


            Parents tend to worry a lot about what their children are watching on TV and how that is affecting them. Ideas of violence, sex, and drugs are put into a lot of the shows aired on television that there is really nothing that is safe. However, are these TV shows really having a lasting effect on the children who watch them? This project is going to focus on the content of television and how young children perceive and understand this content. Do children really understand what is happening when things such as violence happen in TV shows?
            Some of my research done so far includes, “Does Cartoon Violence Beget Aggressive Behavior in Real Life?”  by Fran Blumberg, Kristen Bierwirth, and Allison Schwartz written in a 2008 issue of  Early Childhood Education Journal. They provide an opposing view to the ideas that violence in the media negatively affects children’s behaviors. Mary L Josephson in "Television Violence: A Review of the Effects on Children of Different Ages." looks at children of different ages to see in which developmental stages violence in television begins to have different effects on kids. In Vol. 29 of Early Childhood Education Journal Peters and Blumberg wrote their article “Cartoon Violence: Is It as Detrimental to Preschoolers as We Think?”, this will be a really helpful article to look at as it focuses on the age of children I am interested in. Bjorkqvist and Lagerspetz wrote "Children’s Experience of Three Types of Cartoon at Two Age Levels."  in International Journal of Psychology which looks at different age groups as well as different cartoons to see which, if any, have effects.  "Children's Reactions to Cartoon Violence." by Hapkiewicz written in Journal of Clinical Child Psychology focuses on cartoon violence as opposed to movie or video game violence. "Children's Emotional Reactions to TV Violence: Effects of Film Character, Reassurance, Age, And Sex." is a study done by Surbeck and Endsley in Journal of Social Psychology this study looks at the age and gender and how violence in TV effects them differently. Osborne and Endsley’s article "Emotional Reactions of Young Children to TV Violence." in Child Development is about the emotional effects TV violence has on young children as opposed to behavioral effects. "… Watching TV Violence Places Boys at Risk of Antisocial Behavior." written in Brown University Child & Adolescent Behavior Letter is about the behavior effects TV violence has on boys. Mortimer wrote “How TV Violence Hits Kids” in Education Digest which is also about television violence and children­­­.
            Using on-line databases such as Academic Search Premier I plan on finding more peer-reviewed sources on my topic providing hopefully many different opinions. In addition to that I plan to find some information on early childhood mental development to better understand how young children’s’ minds collect and process information they see in the media. I will try to find some books that may help provide more research on this topic. Finally I will search for studies conducted which shows if television violence does change the way children behave.
            Within the next week I plan on reading through all of my sources I have collected so far, taking notes, and developing a working thesis for my paper. By May 13th I hope to have found studies and books on my topic to help provide more opinions and facts. At this point I plan on being able to begin a rough draft by May 14th giving myself enough time to write it throughout the week that I can bring it into class on May 21st.  After that I will continue on refining and tweaking my paper until it is due June 4th.
Works Cited
Blumberg, Fran, Bierwirth, Kristen and Schwartz, Allison. "Does Cartoon Violence Beget Aggressive Behavior in Real Life? An Opposing View." Early Childhood Education Journal Oct. 2008: 101+. Academic Search Premier. Web. 16 Apr. 2013.
Peters, Kristen M., and Blumberg, Fran C.. "Cartoon Violence: Is It As Detrimental To Preschoolers As We Think?." Early Childhood Education Journal 29.3 (2002): 143. Academic Search Premier. Web. 16 Apr. 2013.
Josephson, Mary L. "Television Violence: A Review of the Effects on Children of Different Ages." N.p., n.d. Web. 16 Apr. 2013.
Bjorkqvist, Kaj, and Lagerspetz, Kirsti. "Childrens Experience Of Three Types Of Cartoon At Two Age Levels." International Journal Of Psychology 20.1 (1985): 77. Academic Search Premier. Web. 16 Apr. 2013.
Hapkiewicz, Walter G. "Children's Reactions to Cartoon Violence." Journal of Clinical Child Psychology 8.1 (1979): 30. Academic Search Premier. Web. 16 Apr. 2013.
Surbeck, Elaine, and Endsley, R.C.. "Children's Emotional Reactions To Tv Violence: Effects Of Film Character, Reassurance, Age, And Sex." Journal of Social Psychology 109.2 (1979): 269. Academic Search Premier. Web. 23 Apr. 2013.
Osborn, D.K., and Endsley, R.C.. "Emotional Reactions of Young Children to TV Violence." Child Development 42.1 (1971): 321. Academic Search Premier. Web. 23 Apr. 2013.
"… Watching TV Violence Places Boys At Risk Of Antisocial Behavior." Brown University Child & Adolescent Behavior Letter 24.1 (2008): 2. Academic Search Premier. Web. 23 Apr. 2013.
"TV Violence and Kids." Education Digest 62.1 (1996): 23. Academic Search Premier. Web. 23 Apr. 2013.
Mortimer, Jeffrey. "How TV Violence Hits Kids." Education Digest 60.2 (1994): 16. Academic Search Premier. Web. 23 Apr. 2013.
Gunter, Barrie, and Jackie Harrison. "Violence In Children's Programmes On British Television." Children & Society 11.3 (1997): 143-156. Academic Search Premier. Web. 23 Apr. 2013.
"Children And TV Violence." Www.aacap.org. American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry., n.d. Web. 23 Apr. 2013.
"The Effects of Television Violence." ThinkQuest. Oracle Foundation, n.d. Web. 23 Apr. 2013.
Boyse, Kyla. "Television and Children." Television (TV) and Children: Your Child:. University of Michigan Health System, Aug. 2010. Web. 23 Apr. 2013.
Kunkel, Dale. "The Effects of Television Violence on Children." : Testimony of Dr. Dale Kunkel, University of Arizona. American Psychological Association, 26 June 2007. Web. 23 Apr. 2013.
“Distribution of Language, Sex, and Violence Codes in PG-Rated Movies”. Chart. parenthood.library.wisc.edu. Web. 23 April 2013
Kirsh, Steven J. "Cartoon Violence and Aggression in Youth." N.p., n.d. Web. 23 Apr. 2013.
Rutenberg, Jim. "Violence Finds a Niche in Children's Cartoons." The New York Times. The New York Times, 28 Jan. 2001. Web. 23 Apr. 2013.
“Percentage of Children of the Two Age Groups Giving Affirmative Answers to Some Crucial Items, and Significances of the Differences.” Chart.
“Children’s Favorite Cartoon Group, by Gender: Children of 18 Primary Schools in Turkey, Data Collection Period December 2010- January 2011” Chart. www.scielo.br. Web. 16 Apr. 2013.

Tuesday, April 23, 2013

Chapter 10

     Chapter 10 is all about field research methods. Field research is good way of learning about an issue because its your own research as apposed to reading someone else's. Field research can allow you to look into different ideas or positions on a issue that may not have been included in published works. The book talks about a few methods of field research such as interviews, observations, surveys, correspondence, and public events and broadcast media. Interviews can provide necessary information or first hand accounts on an issue, but it may not always be the best decision and may just end up completely unnecessary. When planning your interview you need to choose who you will be interviewing as well s what exactly you are going to ask them. The book suggests writing a script, have a list of times that work for you, an estimate of how long it will take, and a suggested location. Observations are better suited for some issues and you must first decide if an observation will benefit you. Once you start planning your observation you need to choose what you will observe as well as how often, what you're looking for, and if you will need permission to observe it. Surveys are good for answering what/who questions and is a good way to collect information on beliefs, attitudes, etc. To decide if a survey is a good method for your research you should look at the kind of information you're looking to gain and if a survey will get that for you. When you plan the survey you need to decide whom and how many people you want to survey, as well as what you are going to ask them and how to ask, if your question is clear enough, and how you are going to get your survey around. Correspondence are any form of communication; email, letters, etc. Public events such as lectures and conferences can provide lots of information for your research as well as examining broadcast media. 

This chapter did well to explain a lot of different research methods I could use for my paper. 

Saturday, April 20, 2013

Chapter 7

         Plagiarism is bad whether it is intentional or not. Most of the time plagiarism is unintentional in the form of a misused quote or not giving credit to someone for their ideas. Sometimes people intentionally plagiarize by taking clips of other people's writings or using fake citations to confuse the reader about the true sources. The chapter talks about research ethics which are what keeps your writing honest and will help your writing to remain accurate and credible. Things that don't necessarily need to be cited are common knowledge and everyday facts. Writers are allowed to use short quotations, summaries, or paraphrases of copy written works and copy writes aren't something most school assignments have to worry about because they most likely won’t be published. Overall to avoid plagiarizing it’s good to have a clear idea and your own opinions on your topic. Taking careful notes paying close attention on properly citing quotations, summaries, and paraphrases.  Once you begin to write you need to distinguish between your own ideas and thoughts and those of your sources, watching for differences in writing styles and the ideas you've drawn from your sources. Finally, sources will need to be marked in the body of the works using the proper formatting.

This chapter is really useful to keep in mind when writing because plagiarism is easy to avoid and benefits no one.

Chapter 6


  Chapter 6 is all about organizing and taking notes on all the information that you will find. In the research you’re going to collect a ton of information and the book gives a few tips to keep them organized and easy to find, like keeping notes in a three ring binder or having a file on your computer. The book also talks about how to organize things digitally using many different things such as email, phone, copy and paste, and bookmarking things on the internet. The next section is about taking notes for your research. Because of all the sources you’re going to come across and all the information you may need to look back on later it’s good to keep notes of important information so you don’t have to search too long for it later. The best way to keep notes is to choose just one method of note taking and to stick to it, if you bounce around with methods too much you may forget about or lose something important. The book also gave a lot of information on quoting your sources and summarizing things to avoid plagiarism. Finally, after all the sources you use and the information you find to avoid plagiarism you need to record who you took information from in the bibliography. There are a lot of different ways of creating bibliographies and this chapter went over a couple of them. 

This chapter was pretty helpful. The parts on note taking and organization will be especially helpful for me during this project. 

Chapter 3

     Chapter 3 is about developing a research question as well as a research proposal. To create a good research question the book says to focus on the who, what, when, where, why, and how's. The first step is to look at your specific writing situation and some of the sources you have already found to decide the conversation and where you want to go with it. Next is to form a list of various research questions focusing on topics such as history, goals, or outcomes. Out of that list of questions written there should be at least one that works for your writing situation and interests you. Once one is chosen it must be expanded on by looking at the who, what, when, where, whys, and hows. Finally you must refine it. Using specific words and phrases, narrowing the scope of the question, and conducting more preliminary searches to find reoccurring conversations.
      Research proposals contain a title page, and introduction, a review of literature, an explanation of how you will collect information, a timeline for the project, and a working bibliography. At this point you should know what your topic is and what you plan to write about, including a working title for your writing. You should show that you have began your research with the review of literature and you should be able to explain how you plan to collect your information. There should be a project timeline you plan to use and a working bibliography.



I found the chapter, specifically the research question section, really helpful while looking into topic ideas because I barely had a clue what I wanted to write about. 

Tuesday, April 16, 2013

Lab Work: Incorporating Sources Effectively


1)A. In “Does Cartoon Violence Beget Aggressive Behavior in Real Life?”  Blumberg, Bierwirth, and Schwartz state, “Non-aggressive children who had been exposed to high levels of media violence showed less activity in the frontal cortex, that area of the brain linked to attention and self-control.”

B. Josephson stated in “Television Violence: A Review of the Effects on Children of Different Ages”, “It has been found that they may not notice or remember important or central aspects of the television content unless these aspects are signalled (sic) by the most obvious formal features of the production.”.

2)A. In Vol. 29 of Early Childhood Education Journal, Peters and Blumberg, in their article in “Cartoon Violence: Is It as Detrimental to Preschoolers as We Think?” wrote, “One contributing factor to this inability to transfer knowledge from the media to daily life is children’s understanding of reality versus fantasy.” Bjorkqvist and Lagerspetz made a similar inference stating, “…preschool children…experience films as a series of separate and fragmentary incidents and not as a continuous story.”

B. Josephson stated in “Television Violence: A Review of the Effects on Children of Different Ages”, “It has been found that they may not notice or remember important or central aspects of the television content unless these aspects are signalled (sic) by the most obvious formal features of the production.”. Similarly, Blumberg, Bierwirth, and Schwartz wrote, “Young children tend to focus much of their attention on observable actions instead of internal causes such as characters’ intentions”.
Works Cited
Blumberg, Fran, Kristen Bierwirth, and Allison Schwartz. "Does Cartoon Violence Beget Aggressive Behavior in Real Life? An Opposing View." Early Childhood Education Journal Oct. 2008: 101+. Academic Search Premier. Web. 16 Apr. 2013.

Peters, Kristen M., and Fran C. Blumberg. "Cartoon Violence: Is It As Detrimental To Preschoolers As We Think?." Early Childhood Education Journal 29.3 (2002): 143. Academic Search Premier. Web. 16 Apr. 2013.

Josephson, Mary L. "Television Violence: A Review of the Effects on Children of Different Ages." N.p., n.d. Web. 16 Apr. 2013.

Bjorkqvist, Kaj, and Kirsti Lagerspetz. "Childrens Experience Of Three Types Of Cartoon At Two Age Levels." International Journal Of Psychology 20.1 (1985): 77. Academic Search Premier. Web. 16 Apr. 2013.

Hapkiewicz, Walter G. "Children's Reactions To Cartoon Violence." Journal Of Clinical Child Psychology 8.1 (1979): 30. Academic Search Premier. Web. 16 Apr. 2013.

“Percentage of Children of the Two Age Groups Giving Affirmative Answers to Some Crucial Items, and Significances of the Differences.” Chart. "Childrens Experience Of Three Types Of Cartoon At Two Age Levels." International Journal Of Psychology 20.1 (1985): 77. Academic Search Premier. Web. 16 Apr. 2013.


“Children’s Favorite Cartoon Group, by Gender: Children of 18 Primary Schools in Turkey, Data Collection Period December 2010- January 2011” Chart. www.scielo.br. Web. 16 Apr. 2013.

Tuesday, April 9, 2013

Chapter 5 Writer's Blog

     Chapter 5 is all about evaluating the sources you find on your topic. The sources need to be relevant to you and what you are writing about; even if something sounds good if it doesn’t fit it's just taking up space. Some of the sources are going to provide you with some evidence to support your topic but not all of it is going to work. To find out if it fits or not you need to look and see if enough evidence is actually offered, if it is the right kind of evidence for your topic, if it is used appropriately and that it comes from a reliable source. You'll also need to evaluate the authors and any publishers you use. To do that you need to look for an author that is knowledgeable on your topic, and to make sure that they lack any biases that may reduce the credibility. Another factor you need to evaluate is when the source was published and if it is still relevant to your topic. You also want a source that fit with how narrow your topic is. Finally you need to evaluate the genre. To do this you need to look at the style of writing, the evidence that is used, how it is organized, citations, and the overall appearance of the document. You need to choose sources that the reader will identify and useful and reliable.

     The second section is about different sources and how to evaluate them. Websites such as blogs and social networking sites, the book suggests learning about the author and approaching them with more caution than you would other sources. Wikis are also tricky because they can be edited by anyone so it’s best to use sites like this just for learning about a topic in the beginning. Overall the chapter reminds you to keep checking any and all sources to make sure they are relevant, reliable, and accurate.
This chapter is super helpful now that we have to start looking into and narrowing our topics, it's really good at this stage to try and keep out biases and focus on only relevant information.

Chapter 2 Writer's Blog

     Chapter 2 began with explain the importance of exploring the topic. Part of exploring the topic is to create a plan including lists of people to talk to about the topic, and lists of resources to use. Another part of exploring the topic is to discuss the topic with others, this includes people with experience/knowledge on the topic, your instructor, etc. Observation was another tool mentioned and is helpful one if the topic involves things one can observe. Next in exploring the topic is looking at work other writers have done on the topic and reviewing the sources. The chapter then goes on to explain and describe all of the different sources that can be used for that step including books, articles, news articles, etc.
     The next section of the chapter talked about focusing on a single issue found in the exploring. To help find this issue look at differentiated opinions, repeated concepts among different sources, and recurring voices. Next is to find where the personal interests lie in the topic that way it will be easier for the writer to put the effort into the piece. The final step is to eventually pick the issue that will be written about and to evaluate it based on questions like will it help me achieve my purposes, will me readers want to read this, and is it appropriate for my project?

This chapter was pretty helpful and explained a lot about how to begin looking into the topic chosen and its really a good place to start.

Chapter 1 Writer's Blog

     The first section of chapter 1 talks all about research and writing about your topic with confidence. To do this you must first take ownership of the project by finding a reason to care about it and a reason to invest in the research. You must also  know what the goal of your writing is and know the writing process necessary to achieve that goal. In your writing you will need to work with information, this includes knowing how to handle sources and keeping your notes organized. You'll need to find a position on your writing and know what you want to convey to your readers. You will also need to know in which genre you will be writing in, this is usually explained in the assignment. To help frame your writing you need to acknowledge who your readers are going to be and know about the historical, cultural, and physical contexts. The last point this section made was to manage your time wisely, I thought that the suggestion of creating a project time line was a good idea.
     The second section of the chapter was all about choosing an appropriate topic for your assignment. To do this you must first analyze your assignment. You need to look at who the readers are and what they are going to want to see. You also will need to think about something you're interested in and what will help keep you motivated through your research. The genre you must use will also play a role so that must be taken into account. You also need to look at the context in which the writings will be read, these include social, cultural, historical, disciplinary, and physical contexts. The type of document you are writing will change the role you must take on as a writer and will effect the way you relate to your readers. The last step in analyzing the project is to acknowledge any requirements, limitations, or opportunities that will change how you work. Once you have an idea about what you want to write about you need to work through it and narrow your focus. To do this you need to brainstorm ideas, free writing and/or looping to expand on good ideas and weed out the useless ones. It also may help once you have all of your ideas together to fit them in a graphical form, called clustering. Finally, once you are sure that you have your topic and you know exactly what you want to write about, go back once more to be sure it fits and is workable.
   
I thought that this chapter was pretty helpful in thinking about what I want to write about for my research paper, especially because I'm still stuck in coming up with ideas.